Should I upload this to AI?

Off

Checklist

Before you upload information or documents into an AI tool, consider the following questions:

  • If this relates to an assessment, does your school or module guidance or assessment brief support using AI in this way?

    • Yes - Remember to retain records and information about how you have used the AI tools, this may be required later when disclosing how you have used AI in your assessment or research, in line with research best practice.

    • No - Pause and think. Uploading course materials to complete assignments where the use of AI is limited may raise issues of academic misconduct.

  • Who owns the material you are uploading?

    • Are you uploading your own work (e.g. your own essay drafts or personal lecture notes). Whilst this might be free from IP infringement (you own the copyright), you should consider if you want your unpublished writing stored by third party tools and potentially used as part of their training data.

    • If the material is not yours, do you have permission from the copyright holder to upload it? For example: this might be another student, the University or a publisher.

    • Are you using openly-licensed material (e.g. under a Creative Commons licence)?

    • Are you uploading lawfully obtained copyrighted material? If so, is your activity covered by a legal exception (e.g. for non-commercial research, private study or teaching). GenAI and copyright guidance.

    • Are you uploading whole copyright materials into University approved generative AI tools for text and data analysis in the context of non-commercial research? Exceptions, fair dealing and reuse.

    • You should be cautious of uploading copyrighted material to a generative AI tool which does not provide assurances regarding data privacy and use of prompts and uploads for training purposes as this increases the risk of infringement.

  • Does the material contain sensitive or identifiable data?

    • For example: names, student IDs, email addresses, or contact information, confidential research data, interview transcripts, or personal participant details.
    • Redact or anonymise all personal data before uploading and only use University approved tools with appropriate data protection and privacy controls.
  • Is this tool university-approved?

    • Yes - Using approved tools via your university account (e.g. Google Gemini) provides extra data privacy protections.
    • No / Unsure - Pause and think. Assume any uploaded data will be stored on third-party servers and potentially used to train public models, increasing exposure to potential copyright infringement claims. 

Other things to consider

Before copy and pasting any documents or information into an AI tool, work through these questions to determine the best course of action:

Pause and consider why you are using AI for this task?

  • Am I solving a clear challenge/problem, or just using AI because it is available? 
  • Is AI capable of handling this specific type of task accurately and reliably? 
  • Will prompting, verifying, and editing the output take longer than doing it myself? 
  • How easily can I verify whether the output is accurate? 
  • Do I have the skills and knowledge to undertake this task without the use of AI? Overreliance on AI summaries can prevent deeper engagement needed for exams and other tasks as part of your studies

Instead of immediately uploading the information into the AI tool, consider whether other options offer a more appropriate way forward:

GoalNon AI Alternative
Clarifying a difficult topicAttend lecturer or module tutor office hours or work in peer study groups. Discussing with peers is one of the advantages of attending university.
Finding academic sourcesFind recommended sources using Reading Lists, StarPlus and other discovery tools, making use of the guidance in StudySkills@Sheffield to support you with this.
Ensuring deeper learningThere is considerable discussion as to whether increased use of genAI leads to ‘cognitive offloading’ and less deep learning. See the Critical GenAI literacy Guide for more information.

You can access additional guidance on using GenAI by visiting the StudySkills@Sheffield GenAI Hub, the Critical GenAI literacy Guide, and the Using AI and GenAI to find information tutorial.

Students sat at a table in discussion

Workshops and 1:1 appointments

Explore a range of workshops and appointments to develop the essential study skills, research, maths and statistics skills that will underpin your learning at university.